QS World University Rankings questioned by IIT-Bombay

Indian Institute of Technology BombayThe authenticity of the QS World University Rankings has been questioned by the scholars at IIT-Bombay, at least in terms of their institute. The students having a doubt on the rankings scrutinized the figures available for the QS World Rankings in 2012 to clarify the doubt. The data of IIT-Bombay and Delhi were compared and some aspects were also compared with the National University of Singapore (NUS). 

The aspects compared include academic and employer reputation which constitute 40% and 10% weightage respectively. Referring to the data on the QS website, the students reached at the conclusion that IIT-Bombay was way ahead of IIT-Delhi but to their surprise IIT-Delhi still succeeded in ranking higher than the institute in Powai.

Another aspect in which IIT-Bombay fares well is that of the student-faculty ratio (SFR), which constitutes 20% weightage. Various discrepancies were witnessed here too. While the figures of SFR for QS stood at 81.4, 35.4 and 28.9 for NUS, IIT-Delhi and IIT-Bombay, the data collected by students depicted a different picture all together. IIT-B’s SFR surpassed even that of NUS. 

Citations per faculty is one area in which the other IITs outweigh IIT-Bombay. But in this context the student’s inspection helped them to reach the conclusion that the papers require citation of an affiliated establishment of research while IIT-B does not restrain a student from stating it in a particular way.  It may be mentioned as IIT-Bombay, I.I.T. Bombay, IIT-Powai or IIT-B and hence may be counted under varied heads.  

Though the QS World Rankings has been in limelight for quite a long time now, but the investigations have revealed that it is full of inconsistencies and is not fool proof. Hence these rankings, whenever used must be considered with some skepticism.


Upto 50% Scholarship on Live Classes

Course Features

  • Video Lectures
  • Revision Notes
  • Previous Year Papers
  • Mind Map
  • Study Planner
  • NCERT Solutions
  • Discussion Forum
  • Test paper with Video Solution