Flag Discuss with colleagues and IITians> are-indian-people-good-at-mathematics...
question mark

Are people from INDIA good at Mathematics??

sneha singh , 11 Years ago
Grade 12
anser 2 Answers
rake

Last Activity: 11 Years ago

Since the question is based on an assumption which is not verified/correct. Also, spreading unverified information to impose your ideology is wrong. I remember those email forwards in school where it used to start with how Vedic science is more advanced than present, and the best brains in all top notch companies are Indians and ended with Jan Gan is voted the best national song by UN. The assumption here is no less flawed than those cases.

Ramanujan was a great mathematician but extrapolating that to generalize Indians in mathematics is similar to saying since Abhinav Bindra won a gold, Indians are good in Olympics.

I don't think Indians are very good at Mathematics though they are good when it comes to basic school maths, calculation speed and mental calculations. Mathematics is much more than that.


The Olympiad again only checks understanding for high school students and cannot be generalized to say how good people are at Mathematics but this data clearly shows we are not the best at high school mathematics, not even close.

Hrishant Goswami

Last Activity: 11 Years ago

The question is similiar to "why are all Romanians/Bulgarians/Russians good at programming". This is self-selection at work. Although all the Romanians I have seen are strong programmers, it doesn`t mean that all of Romania is doing programming. It is just a small non-random sample we are seeing. Same with Indians. That said, Indians tend to be relatively better at math than other disciplines. At any point of time you will see more mathematicians & engineers than say archeologists and mountain climbers. From ancient history, the Indians have placed a lot of emphasis on math. The religion/culture always rewarded mathematicians of the likes of Aryabhatta, Bhaskaracharya, Brahmagupta, etc. (Even after 1500 years they retain their brand and we named our initial satellites after them.) One of the dominant occupations among Indians from ancient era was trading & accounting. Indian traders went all over Southeast Asia and Africa. Even in British era, a lot of accounting/inventory management in the colonies were done by Indians. Culturally, doing math was always considered really attractive in India. A kid with supreme math skills is a genius and considered a "rockstar". On the other hand, in the US the same kid will be called a "nerd", "dork" or whatever negative epithet those with no math skills can think of. Culturally, US & Europe are biased against people with math talent and biased towards those who throw balls or play strings. Other than medicine, almost all lucrative career options in India require a strong math background. These include engineering, accounting (CA), finance and business administration. Even if you don`t get educated you start a small business and again you need counting skills there. Kids are taught the reality that, without math our career won`t go anywhere. Even illiterates are good in basic arithmetic as it is a matter of survival. Our schools tend to place a lot of emphasis on basic math skills. My secondary school teacher would kill me if I ever used a calculator. I spent most of my secondary & highschool with those darn, purple Clark`s tables. Some of my classmates used to memorize all sorts of random things (like all Greek alphabets) form that book. A lot of us did close to 50-70 math problems everyday during that time.

Provide a better Answer & Earn Cool Goodies

Enter text here...
star
LIVE ONLINE CLASSES

Prepraring for the competition made easy just by live online class.

tv

Full Live Access

material

Study Material

removal

Live Doubts Solving

assignment

Daily Class Assignments


Ask a Doubt

Get your questions answered by the expert for free

Enter text here...