Question icon
Grade 11Thermal Physics

There is a cylindrical container having Oxygen....\gamma=1.4, which is covered by a 50Kg frictionless piston.

Area of piston=100cm2, atm.Press=100KPa g=10m/s2.

Cylinder is heated slowly, which raises its piston by 20cm.....Find the heat given....

[My logic was since the process is slow, its isothermal, thus Change in temp=0, H=Pdv. Answer is not coming, point out my flaw.]

Profile image of Radhika Batra
12 Years agoGrade 11
Answers icon

1 Answer

Profile image of Askiitians Tutor Team
ApprovedApproved Tutor Answer11 Months ago

Let's break down the problem step by step to clarify where the misunderstanding might be. You have a cylindrical container with oxygen, a piston, and you're heating the system slowly, which leads you to think the process is isothermal. However, let's analyze the situation more closely.

Understanding the System

You have a piston with a mass of 50 kg and an area of 100 cm². The atmospheric pressure is given as 100 kPa, and the gravitational acceleration is 10 m/s². The piston moves up by 20 cm when the gas is heated. The key here is to determine the type of process occurring and how to calculate the heat transfer.

Identifying the Process

While you mentioned that the process is isothermal (meaning the temperature remains constant), this is not necessarily the case. Since the gas is being heated, it is likely that the temperature of the gas increases, leading to an expansion of the gas and a rise in the piston. Therefore, we cannot assume that the temperature change is zero.

Calculating the Work Done

To find the heat given to the system, we first need to calculate the work done by the gas as it expands. The work done (W) by the gas can be calculated using the formula:

  • W = P * ΔV

Where P is the pressure and ΔV is the change in volume. To find ΔV, we can use the area of the piston and the distance it moves:

  • ΔV = A * h

Here, A is the area of the piston (in m²) and h is the height the piston moves (in meters). Let's convert the area:

  • A = 100 cm² = 0.01 m²
  • h = 20 cm = 0.2 m

Now, we can calculate ΔV:

  • ΔV = 0.01 m² * 0.2 m = 0.002 m³

Finding the Pressure

The pressure exerted by the gas can be calculated using the weight of the piston and the area:

  • P = F/A

Where F is the force due to the weight of the piston:

  • F = m * g = 50 kg * 10 m/s² = 500 N

Now, substituting into the pressure formula:

  • P = 500 N / 0.01 m² = 50000 Pa = 50 kPa

Calculating Work Done

Now we can calculate the work done by the gas:

  • W = P * ΔV = 50 kPa * 0.002 m³ = 100 J

Heat Transfer Calculation

In a process where the gas is heated and does work, the first law of thermodynamics applies:

  • ΔU = Q - W

Where ΔU is the change in internal energy, Q is the heat added to the system, and W is the work done by the system. If we assume that the internal energy change is equal to the heat added (which is a common assumption for ideal gases), we can rearrange this to find Q:

  • Q = ΔU + W

However, since we don't have the change in internal energy directly, we need to consider that for an ideal gas, the internal energy change is related to temperature change. If we assume the gas behaves ideally and heats up, we can estimate Q based on the work done and the expected temperature change.

In summary, the flaw in your logic was assuming the process was isothermal when in fact, heating the gas likely caused a temperature increase, leading to work done by the gas. Therefore, the heat added to the system should be calculated considering the work done and the change in internal energy, which is influenced by the temperature change. If you have specific values for the heat capacity of the gas, you could calculate the exact heat added more accurately.