Question icon
Grade 10Thermal Physics

Consider a lake of depth 1m.the temperature of the surrounding atmosphere is (-100C) . the bottom of the lake is maintained at 40C . find the maximum thickness ice that would form .


density of ice is 10^3 kg/m3


latent heat of fusion of ice is 3.36*10^5


Kice=1.7


Kwater=0.5


this is hc verma qstn 16 from heat transfer.

Profile image of Aditi Chauhan
12 Years agoGrade 10
Answers icon

1 Answer

Profile image of Askiitians Tutor Team
ApprovedApproved Tutor Answer1 Year ago

To determine the maximum thickness of ice that can form on a lake with a depth of 1 meter, where the bottom is maintained at 4°C and the surrounding atmosphere is at -10°C, we can apply concepts from heat transfer. The key factors to consider are the heat loss from the water surface to the atmosphere and the heat required to freeze the water into ice.

Understanding Heat Transfer

Heat transfer occurs through conduction, convection, and radiation. In this scenario, we primarily deal with conduction and convection. The heat loss from the water surface to the atmosphere will cause the water to freeze, forming ice. The rate of heat loss can be expressed using Newton's law of cooling:

Q = hA(T_water - T_air)

  • Q = heat transfer rate (W)
  • h = heat transfer coefficient (W/m²K)
  • A = surface area (m²)
  • T_water = temperature of the water (4°C)
  • T_air = temperature of the air (-10°C)

Calculating Heat Loss

Assuming a typical value for the heat transfer coefficient, h, for air is around 10 W/m²K, we can calculate the heat loss per square meter of the lake surface:

Q = 10 * 1 * (4 - (-10)) = 10 * 1 * 14 = 140 W/m²

Heat Required to Freeze Water

Next, we need to calculate how much heat is required to freeze a certain thickness of ice. The heat required to freeze a volume of water can be calculated using the formula:

Q_fusion = m * L_f

  • m = mass of the water that freezes (kg)
  • L_f = latent heat of fusion of ice (3.36 x 10^5 J/kg)

The mass of the water that freezes can be expressed in terms of the thickness of the ice (d) and the area (A):

m = ρ_water * A * d

Substituting this into the heat equation gives:

Q_fusion = ρ_water * A * d * L_f

Setting Up the Equation

Now, we can set the heat loss equal to the heat required to freeze the water:

140 = 1000 * d * 3.36 x 10^5

Here, we used the density of water (ρ_water = 1000 kg/m³). Now, we can solve for d:

140 = 1000 * d * 3.36 x 10^5

Rearranging gives:

d = 140 / (1000 * 3.36 x 10^5)

d = 140 / 3.36 x 10^8

d ≈ 4.16 x 10^-7 m

Maximum Thickness of Ice

This value indicates that the maximum thickness of ice that can form under these conditions is approximately 0.000416 m, or 0.416 mm. However, this is a theoretical calculation based on steady-state conditions and assumes that all heat loss goes into freezing the water. In reality, factors such as wind, water movement, and thermal stratification can affect the actual thickness of ice formed.

In summary, the maximum thickness of ice that would form on the lake, given the specified conditions, is approximately 0.416 mm. This example illustrates the delicate balance of heat transfer processes in natural bodies of water and how environmental conditions can significantly influence physical states. Understanding these principles is crucial in fields such as environmental science and engineering.