Question icon
Grade 12th passOrganic Chemistry

Which is more stable cation-cyclo propyl methyl cation or cyclo propenyl cation

Profile image of Subhadip
6 Years agoGrade 12th pass
Answers icon

3 Answers

Profile image of Shivananda Nayak
6 Years ago
The cyclo propyl methyl cation is more stable due to dancing resonance. This carboction is an example of non classical carbocation.601-2227_New Doc 04-04-2020 17.09.09_3.jpg
Profile image of Vikas TU
ApprovedApproved Tutor Answer6 Years ago
Dear student
In cyclopropyl methyl carbocation, the sigma electron cloud expands outwardly due to angle strain; therefore, the valence electron cloud of CH2+ is surrounded by or enveloped by the expanded electron cloud making carbocation stable.
Good Luck 
Profile image of Subhadip
6 Years ago
Cyclopropenyl ion is an aromatic compound and can be stored in bottle. But cyclopropyl methyl cation can not be stored in bottle,so aromatic character is more predominating.than dancing reso.