Question icon
Grade upto college level Magnetism

In the following diagram we have 2 wires carrying current and they are not welded.

Now anaylyse the force on the wires due to each other and see that the reaction is not equal to action. Even the direction of force is not same.

Is this a violation of Newton's 3rd law or if it is not where is the lost momentum

Profile image of Kevin Nash
12 Years agoGrade upto college level
Answers icon

1 Answer

Profile image of Askiitians Tutor Team
ApprovedApproved Tutor Answer1 Year ago

To analyze the interaction between two parallel wires carrying current, we need to delve into the forces they exert on each other and how this relates to Newton's Third Law of Motion. At first glance, it might seem like there's a violation of this law, but let's break it down step by step.

The Basics of Current-Carrying Wires

When electric current flows through a wire, it generates a magnetic field around it. If you have two wires carrying current, they will interact with each other's magnetic fields. The direction of the current in each wire determines the nature of the force between them.

Understanding the Forces

Consider two parallel wires, Wire A and Wire B. If both wires carry current in the same direction, they will attract each other. Conversely, if the currents flow in opposite directions, the wires will repel each other. This interaction can be explained using the right-hand rule, which helps visualize the direction of the magnetic fields and the resulting forces.

Newton's Third Law in Context

Newton's Third Law states that for every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction. In the case of our wires, when Wire A exerts a force on Wire B, Wire B exerts an equal and opposite force on Wire A. However, the key point here is that these forces are not acting on the same object; they are acting on different objects (the wires themselves).

Analyzing the Forces

  • Force on Wire A: If Wire A attracts Wire B, it experiences a force directed towards Wire B.
  • Force on Wire B: Wire B experiences an equal force directed towards Wire A.

Although the magnitudes of the forces are equal, the direction of the forces is opposite, which aligns perfectly with Newton's Third Law. The confusion often arises when considering the system as a whole versus the individual components.

Where is the Lost Momentum?

In this scenario, there is no lost momentum. The forces between the wires are internal to the system of the two wires. When they exert forces on each other, they do not lose momentum; instead, they exchange momentum. The total momentum of the system remains conserved. If Wire A moves slightly towards Wire B due to the attraction, Wire B will also experience a corresponding change in momentum, ensuring that the overall momentum of the system remains constant.

Conclusion

In summary, the interaction between two current-carrying wires does not violate Newton's Third Law. The forces they exert on each other are equal in magnitude and opposite in direction, acting on different objects. The momentum is conserved within the system, and there is no loss of momentum. This fascinating interplay of electricity and magnetism illustrates the principles of physics beautifully.