Flag Algebra> Prove that total number of commutative bi...
question mark

Prove that total number of commutative binary operations on a set consisting of n elements is nn(n-1)/2

Garvita Srivastava , 7 Years ago
Grade 12
anser 2 Answers
Anish Singhal
Let Abe a set with nelements. We want functionsf:A×A⟶A such thatf(x,y)=f(y,x) for allx,y∈A.

Let us writeA×A=J∪K={(x,x)|x∈A}∪{(x,y)|x≠y,x,y∈A}.
Observe that|J|=n and|K|=n^2−n.To define fon A×A, we need to define fon Jand onK.

For each (x,x)∈Jwe can assign any of the nvalues of A, this means we have a totality ofn^nchoices.
Without any restrictions, for each (x,y)∈Kwe can assign any of then^nvalues ofAAbut for commutativity we have to assign the same value forf(x,y) andf(y,x) so in fact we can only assign values to n^2−n^2pairs (x,y)∈K. Thus there are a totality ofn^(n2−n)^2 choices.

So in all the number of commutative binary functions on Ais:n^n⋅n^(n2−n)2=n^n(n+1)2.
Last Activity: 7 Years ago
ASWIN BABURAJ
Since operation is commutative
a*b=b*a
No of possible way to select a and b is
nC2=n(n-1)/2
Each a*b can have images only from given set (Since * is binary)
Then each a*b can have n possible images
   Then total no of commutative binary operation on a set with n elements is
            nn(n-1)/2
Last Activity: 6 Years ago
star
LIVE ONLINE CLASSES

Prepraring for the competition made easy just by live online class.

tv

Full Live Access

material

Study Material

removal

Live Doubts Solving

assignment

Daily Class Assignments